• 72°

You Decide: Should North Carolina follow California or Texas?

By Dr. Mike Walden

Both California and Texas have developed dominating economies in recent decades. The states are one and two in both size of their economy and population. If each were countries, California would have the fifth largest economy in the world and Texas would be the ninth largest.

Yet one of the oddities making these accomplishments noteworthy is they were achieved with very different economic models. California is a high-tax, high public spending state, whereas Texas is the opposite – a low-tax, low public spending state. Can North Carolina learn anything from these two states with their different approaches to economic development?

First, here’s some background on California and Texas and reasons why they have approached their economies so differently.

California and Texas have developed their economies around very different business sectors. Technology and entertainment are huge movers of the California economy. The state’s Silicon Valley – a region around San Jose – is the headquarters for numerous global tech firms as well as start-ups. The production of movies, TV shows and music – involving tens of thousands of jobs – has been a major component of the California economy since the 1920s.

In contrast, today’s Texas economy revolves around energy and manufacturing. Texas is a major producer of oil and natural gas and it refines those resources into finished fuel products. A maze of fuel pipelines sprouts out from Texas to all parts of the country.

The different economies of the two states mean different workforces. California’s workforce includes a large percentage of highly educated and professional workers at the top of the pay scale and an equally high percentage of service jobs at the lower end of the pay scale, with fewer middle-income jobs in-between. As a result, income inequality in the state is very high, with California ranking fourth among states in the unequal distribution of income.

Texas, meanwhile, has an income distribution that provides relatively more middle-income jobs than California, but also relatively more lower income jobs and fewer higher income jobs. Texas ranks below California and below the national average on income inequality.

These economic differences between California and Texas can provide an explanation for the opposite tax and public spending policies each state follows. In California, high income taxpayers in a very income-unequal state may feel an obligation to pay more taxes in order to fund more generous social programs for low-income residents. Additionally, the elite tech companies attract a highly educated workforce, one that often comes with a more favorable view of income redistribution.

With its more equalitarian workforce, residents of Texas may be less inclined to pay higher taxes to support better funded social programs. Their attitude may be more tilted to a “pull yourself up by your bootstraps” philosophy.

Currently, North Carolina’s economy is more like Texas than California. Manufacturing’s share of our state’s economy is 70 percent higher than in California, but it is also 30 percent greater than in Texas. The tech sector’s share of the North Carolina economy is the same as in Texas, but the tech share in both states is 60 percent under California’s share. The split between upper income, middle income and lower income jobs is almost identical for Texas and North Carolina and income inequality in North Carolina is slightly lower than in Texas and much below California. The biggest difference between the North Carolina and Texas economies is the large size of the energy sector in the Lone Star state.

The state fiscal policies of North Carolina and Texas are also similar. The Tax Foundation ranks North Carolina 10th best and Texas 11th best for tax systems attractive to business expansion. California is ranked 49th. Both Texas and North Carolina are below the average of state spending as a percent of the economy, while California is above the average.

Two key questions are, where does North Carolina want to go from here, and what kind of policy will take the state there? If North Carolina wants to focus on attracting businesses that are labor intensive and increase middle-income jobs, then the current policy may be the best fit. If the state wants to expand its footprint in the technology and professional areas in order to attract higher paying jobs and top educated workers, then making policy more like California’s may be appropriate.

Of course, there are debates about both the California and Texas models. Recently, California has lost some population and companies who, in part, have complained of the state’s high tax rates. At the same time, Texas’s model has been criticized for being too stingy in funding public services and relying too heavily on more regressive taxes.

Ultimately the debate about the best fiscal policy will be decided by North Carolina’s residents. If in the future more of those residents are highly educated professionals working in high-paying industries – such as technology – then North Carolina could easily migrate closer to the California model. Conversely, if most of the state’s future growth is in sectors like manufacturing, agribusiness and perhaps energy, then the pendulum could swing the other way to favoring the Texas model. Either way, the decision will be a “collective you decide.”

Dr. Mike Walden is a William Neal Reynolds Distinguished Professor Emeritus at North Carolina State University.

FOR MORE COLUMNS AND LETTERS TO THE EDITOR, CHECK OUT OUR OPINION SECTION HERE.

News

Recreational and commercial flounder seasons adjusted for 2021

Business

Frosties: Serving up sweet treats on Roanoke Island

Crime

North Carolina man arrested for shooting at sheriff’s deputy

Crime

Pursuit into Moyock leads to arrest of Norfolk woman for multiple charges

Crime

North Carolina woman pleads guilty to wire fraud, making false statements

News

Falling short: Why the White House will miss its COVID-19 vaccination target

News

Medical marijuana legalization in North Carolina gets hearing in Senate

News

ECU, Vidant Health to clinically integrate, create ECU-branded academic health system

Currituck

Two vehicles involved in Currituck County wreck

Crime

North Carolina man accused of killing girlfriend, transporting body to Tennessee

News

North Carolina woman scores $100,000 lottery prize

News

Draft compatibility determination for replacing Ryders Creek Bridge out for review

Business

Angie Matthews named Outer Banks Hospital Employee of the Month for June

Crime

North Carolina man arrested in fatal shooting

Crime

North Carolina man pleads guilty to theft of government property, Social Security fraud

News

Several scenic byway signs have been stolen since original installation

News

Extensive damage reported in early morning Kill Devil Hills structure fire

News

Bill raising minimum North Carolina marriage age to 16 continues to advance

News

Set of family birthdays win Perquimans County woman $100,000 Cash 5 jackpot

Business

Ribbon cutting held for Island Guesthouse & Motel

Crime

North Carolina man charged in roadside shooting incident

News

Jamie Whitley honored by North Carolina Association of Municipal Clerks

News

Sheriff’s office investigating infant drowning in bathtub at North Carolina home

Business

Long & Foster Real Estate office celebrated with grand opening and ribbon cutting event